Performance differences between Magic Pie and 1000w HBS motor

[Andrew]

Hi folks,

can anyone elaborate,

here's a Magic Pie motor data chart  http://www.goldenmotor.com/magicpie/MP-performance%20data%2048V.pdf    

and here's 1000w HBS motor chart http://www.goldenmotor.com/e-Bike-DIY/HBS-48V1000W%20Performance%20Data.pdf


What are the main differences?  Where does the Magic Pie out perform the HBS motor?

Andrew  

P.S I know this is just a paper exercise and does not compare to a real experienced back to back test, just wnated to know where on paper the benefits lie on the MP