Hi Hastings,
Hey, I have to tell you there is a reason some current interrupters are called "Switches", and others are called "Connectors". Switches are typically design rated for millions of operations, while connectors are designed for a few thousand operations. I have been using a 100A rated battery isolation switch, but if you look at my battery connection contacts, there are clear signs of damage from arc sputtering, and I would guess yours is the same. The tin coating on the contacts is easily sputtered by the high current of initial contact. If you can get some gold plated contacts, that would be a better choice as gold does not sputter well. Small sized gold plated high current connectors are available from hobby shops that deal in electric model racers, drones, etc. Hobby King is where I got mine on line. I don't remember the brand name.
TTFN,
Dennis